Mutilate for PvE, Part II: Combat

It’s essential. Your role is as clearly defined as any class in the World of Warcraft. You do one thing, and you do it very well. Deal damage. Burst. Sustained. Even damage over time (the lesser known advantage of the Subtlety talents).

Traditionally, rogue dps is thought of in two ways: PvE and PvP. Either you have specialized yourself through talent points to be most effective for instancing and raiding, or battlegrounds and arenas. Can one specialization work for the other’s purpose? In a word, yes. I will always believe that regardless of talent spec, what makes any toon worth his or her weight in primal mights is the person at the controls. But, having said that and for the purposes of this post, I want to consider all things normal in that respect.

As far as rogue talent builds go, 15/41/5 (or some general variation of) combat daggers/swords/fists will produce the highest sustained damage over the course of any instance or raid (I dont consider combat maces to be viable for any sort of PvE, since the stun effect will be resisted by most instance and raid bosses…I know, kind of contradictory to the main point of the previous paragraph. Meh, I digress.) The primary talents, such as improved slice and dice, adrenaline rush, combat potency, aggression, and improved [weapon] are specifically designed for a rogue to maximize white damage and increase the base damage of skills. But what if we took the foundation of the combat build and married it to the burst damage of the mutilate build?

A few posts ago, I went through what I feel to be the best distribution of talent points in the assassination tree (for the purposes of raiding and PvE). Here, I want to review how to use your remaining 20 points in the combat tree and how to pull it all together to give you a very potent, very powerful and fun build.

Improved Gouge3/3 – Increases the effect duration of your Gouge ability by 1.5 seconds
Why? Because you’re going to be grinding alot, and your main attack is still made from behind. This ability gives you a short break in battle to regenerate energy and reposition yourself for that wonderful burst damage. However, there is an interesting contradiction here. Since I am going with vile poisons, I use deadly poisons almost always. Gouge is broken by any damage, including periodic DoTs. Alas, this talent becomes highly useful when I am grinding and aggro an extra mob (ogres, elementals, etc.), and need a bit of extra crowd control.

Improved Sinister Strike2/2 – Reduces the cost of your Sinister Strike ability by 5
Two of the first 10 talent points a rogue spends will go here. You wont use this very often, but when you need it, you really need it. If the situation requires you to not or prohibits you from being behind an enemy, well, you get the point.

Improved Slice and Dice3/3 – Increases the duration of your Slice and Dice ability by 45%
As I so gracefully discussed with poor math, this post, Slice and Dice is really one of your most important finishers. Simply, you attack faster; you hit your target more times per second and you apply more poisons per second. Putting 3 points in this talent means you can keep Slice an Dice up for a longer amount of time while freeing up combo points for other finishers.

Precision5/5 – Increases your chance to hit with melee weapons by 5%
Rogues, well, we miss alot. Enemies can dodge. One thing that I notice alot about rogues (since in neurotic and need to check every rogue I see on armory) is that they don’t pay enough attention to their hit rating. I haven’t the slightest idea how to calculate it (which means I’m just too lazy to look it up right now), but I know it makes a big difference in your damage dealt. Either way, this talent isn’t one that any rogue will argue…you put 5 points in here for the hit, but you really want that Dual Wield Specialization…

Dual Wield Specialization5/5 – Increases the damage done by your offhand weapon by 50%
Remember, this is a Mutilate build intended for PvE situations. It’s the beauty of burst damage with all the benefits of sustained dps, and this talent is where it all comes together. As a rule, offhand weapon damage is reduced by 50%. With this talent, that becomes 25%. Simple enough, right? Right. White damage, normalized. Check. But something that is largely unknown is that this talent also increases your offhand Mutilate damage. Don’t believe me? Allow me to plagiarize: “Previously, the Mutilate Bonus Damage was listed as being reduced by the offhand penalty. However, it is in fact not reduced by the offhand penalty. Also, not only is the bonus damage not reduced, 5/5 DW Specialization increases it by 50%. This means the offhand bonus ends up being 101 if you don’t have DW Specialization, and 151.5 if you have 5/5 DW Specialization.” Check out the calculation here. Is it as much of an increase as Opportunity? No, not at first glance. At least not to Mutilate. But Opportunity does nothing for your offhand. And in a long instance or raid, your white damage is more vaulable than your burst damage.

Endurance2/2 – Reduces the cooldown of your Sprint and Evasion abilities by 1.5 minutes
Not my favorite cooldown reduction talent. I like Camouflage better, and Elusiveness the most. But well, we’re not in the Subtlety tree at all…so this will do. I do use evasion quite often when grinding, just to increase my survivability, so having it’s cooldown reduced is nice. The main purpose for putting two points here is to reach Dual Wield Spec. It’s not going to make or break the build if you choose to put two points in Improved Sprint, or even split 1 point to each.

I wish I had more time today to bring it all together, but I think I could take a whole entire post just for that. There is such a ridiculously high rate of combo point generation with this build that you really need to pay attention to your energy ticks and time your finishers to keep Find Weakness up as much as possible. Until next time, if anyone has experience with this build and wants to share their own findings, I’d love to hear them.

9 Responses to Mutilate for PvE, Part II: Combat

  1. Jeanclaudia says:

    Hi Doomilias, saw your post at Roguespot and its a nice read!

    However Im not convinced about the OH-damage of Mutilate not being affected by DW-penalty, which is how I understand your point.

    I think youre missing the word “bonus” that is liberally littered all over the Wowwiki-entry.

    What this means is that the Mutilate OH-attack will be X * 0.5 + 101 without 5/5 DW-specialization, and X * 0.75 + 151.5 with 5/5 DW.

  2. Jeanclaudia says:

    Hmm I read your text again and realized my comment should have been posted on Part I of your otherwise awesome 41/20 critique… Cant edit this away either since i cant be arsed to get a Blgger-account:-/

  3. Vorian says:

    Small request/suggestion. Could you put this build (the 2/3 from Part I and this 1/3) at the bottom of your page as a wow head build?

    I’m sure the wonderfull and talented BRK can tell you how if you dont know.

    I look forward to using your info and opinions when i level my rogue alt.

    Vorian Anderhol US-pvp

  4. Anonymous says:

    I’ve been using this build in BG’s and Arena. (cept i put two in improved sprint for the Arena) With no talents in Subtlety, its average for BG’s imo. It is THE spec for 2 vs 2 Arena teams. I’m paired with a BM hunter and we rarely lose.

  5. Somina says:

    Hey man, read your post and I like to see another’s point of view on mutilate specs. Not posting this to argue any points or anything. I’m just trying to discuss builds with someone else who has an understanding of the class.

    So, if you don’t mind taking the time, look up my character on the armory and check out his spec. I primarily use the build for PvE but I do PvP every now and then. My biggest thoughts are your opinion of Opportunity Vs. DW Spec. The only other major benefit I see in the combat tree would be the hit increase.

    I know there are many other factors to figure in, but I wouldn’t mind having someone critique the build because with what I’m using, I still maintain highest or second highest damage in parties and raids and rarely pull threat off tanks.

    Shattered Hand (U.S.)

  6. Subhodeep says:

    Good post. Just one thing: Dual wield mutilate will always out damage opportunity mutilate.

  7. Subhodeep says:

    Oh, and one more thing: I personally find Improved Sprint a lot more useful.

    Definitely in PvP, but also in PvE, and allows you to save CloS for situations that are more dire.

  8. Doomilias says:

    sub…i used to have imp sprint too. just a matter of preference i think. i wish theyd switch endurance with imp kick. that 100% 2 second silence would be so much better. but if they did all the mages and locks would cry even more than they do about CoS.

  9. Coconuter says:

    For not knowing the calculations of hit rating, here ya go.

    15.8 hit rating = 1% to hit.

    With patch 2.3, 363 hit rating is needed to reach hit cap (assuming you have the 5% to hit talents).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: